PMQs Watch – Corbyn’s Crowdsourcing

PMQs saw a new leader of the opposition (LO) on Wednesday, Jeremy Corbyn, who won a rather surprising victory in the Labour party leadership election. Corbyn’s first appearance and performance at PMQs was scrutinised very carefully by the media demonstrating the importance of this weekly event in the House of Commons.

When Corbyn stood up for the first time there was a resounding cheer from the Labour benches for their new leader. The Conservative benches were surprisingly quiet. In the past they would often cheer the Leader of the Opposition, Ed Miliband, as he stood up in a mocking tone to suggest that he does not get enough support from his own benches. They clearly took a principled decision not to do that for Corbyn’s first PMQs but it remains to be seen whether they will continue like this in the future.

Corbyn indicated that he hoped that PMQs would take on a different tone and be less ‘theatrical’ than it had been in the past. He referred back to David Cameron’s appeal for a more civilised question time in 2005 when he first became leader of the opposition. New leaders often make this sort of appeal when first standing up at the despatch box during PMQs but the tone often descends into ‘Punch and Judy’ politics as time passes. Conversation is a ‘joint enterprise’ and so the tone is not only dependent on what Corbyn wants, but also what the Prime Minister wants. And, importantly, what the chamber wants since the audience, as I have argued in the past, is a partner in this joint enterprise.

Corbyn came to power largely due to the support from ordinary members of the Labour party rather than the sitting Labour MPs. In fact, many of the Labour MPs have been openly hostile to Corbyn and his ‘hard-left’ political ideas. It was probably rather fitting then that he chose to source his questions not from the backbenches but from ordinary members of the public who had replied to his email request for questions. It was because of this that several commentators called him a ‘tribune to the people’.

The Power of Evidentiality

In conversation, overtly stating the source of a question can often be a powerful device since it provides the evidentiality for the proposition and thus lends legitimacy and urgency to the question. Politicians often like to phrase and mention questions from leading luminaries, groups or research institutes in order to validate their questions.

Corbyn’s crowdsourcing of questions from the general public had the effect of disarming Cameron leaving him with no option but to answer the questions sincerely and openly. Corbyn (LO) made sure that each question was prefaced with the name of the questioner:

LO: from a woman called Marie who says ...
LO: I ask a question (.) from Claire (.)
    who says this ...
LO: Paul for example (.)
    says this very heartfelt question

External link to clip

Sometime Corbyn would state the role of the questioner to further provide legitimacy to the question:

LO: I’ve got a question (.) from Stephen (.)
    who works for a housing association
LO: I ask a question from (.) Angela
    who’s a mental health professional (.)
    so she knows exactly what she’s talking about

The effect of mentioning the first name of each questioner was to prevent Cameron from attacking the basis of each question and the presuppositions on which it was based. Cameron (PM) in return often used the name of the questioner in his reply to indicate empathy with the public:

PM: now let me answer very directly (.) Marie’s question
PM: what I would say to Stephen
    and all those working in housing associations
    and and doing a good job
PM: what I would say to Angela

External link to clip

A change in tone with Angus Robertson

An interesting change in tone and attitude was observed in Cameron’s style when Angus Robertson, the leader of the SNP, got up to ask his two allotted questions. Cameron’s first reply exhibited a raised voice, exaggerated tones and dismissive looks which were indicative of the style he often employed with Ed Miliband during the Punch-and-Judy days. Notice also how the chamber contributes to the change in tone of the discourse though the partisan ‘shouts of agreement’:

PM: we have delivered on ALL of the promises that we made
Chamber:  ((shouts of agreement))
PM: we said (.) we said 
    we would introduce a Scotland bill 
    we introduced a Scotland bill 
    we said unprecedented devolution on taxes
    there’s been unprecedented devolution on taxes
    we said that we’d provide those welfare powers
    we’ve given those welfare powers
    the question is now for the SNP
    when are you gonna stop talking about processes
    and when are you gonna start telling us
    what taxes you’re gonna put up
    what welfare changes you’re gonna be made
    or are you (.)
    when it comes to talking about the issue (.) frit

External link to clip

The word ‘frit’ is slang for frightened and is occasionally used in the House of Commons but has a rather harsh tone. Example of thatcher using the word ‘frit’ in 1983 – external link

Cameron’s body language and facial expressions also changed to reflect the adversarial mood of Cameron.

cameron_facial_expresssions
Cameron’s facial expressions and Robertson’s look of dismay

Robertson seemed quite taken aback by Cameron’s sudden attack and reminded him of the promise he’d made for the new style of PMQs. In reply, Cameron said it would take some getting used to, and his subsequent reply was calmer and more measured. He even corrected his own use of personal pronoun ‘you’ to ‘he’ which is considered more formal in the House of Commons:

PM: you give me a list (.)
    sorry (.)
    he should give me a list

External link to clip

Advertisements

One thought on “PMQs Watch – Corbyn’s Crowdsourcing

Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: